How Does the Hague Convention Apply to a Child Custody Case?

Child custody (Parental Responsibilities) disputes can be emotionally draining, but when the involved parents reside in different countries, the situation becomes even more complex. That’s where the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction comes in. 

With the increased mobility of couples, international child custody cases are becoming more common. Whether couples decide to live abroad or receive international jobs, child custody disputes that cross international borders are on the rise. Under the Hague Convention, children who are wrongfully abducted from the country where they live must be returned to that country, so that custody disputes can be resolved there.

In this blog, we will explore the implications of international child custody cases and discuss how the Hague Convention can provide assistance in resolving disputes. Here’s what you need to know.

WHY THE HAGUE CONVENTION IS IMPORTANT

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is a crucial international agreement that deals with international parental child abduction. This treaty provides a legal process that allows a parent to seek the return of their child to their home country. The Convention was developed by the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) and entered into force on December 1, 1983. 

Numerous countries worldwide have joined the treaty, which aims to prevent wrongful removal or retention of a child from their habitual residence. The Convention considers any removal or retention that breaches custody rights attributed to a person or any other body as “wrongful,” regardless of whether the parent has legal custody. In many cases, U.S. court orders may not be recognized in other countries, and sovereign nations cannot interfere with each other’s legal systems. Therefore, the Hague Convention provides an essential framework for resolving international child custody disputes.

HAGUE CONVENTION FRAMEWORK

The Hague Convention’s framework helps countries work together to find solutions for custody cases where a child is abducted, regardless of the child’s immigration status or nationality. If a child is taken from their habitual home and brought to a foreign country, it violates the parent’s custodial rights.

The Central Authority can help with the following: 

  • Serves as the main point of contact for parents and children in international child custody cases.
  • Help locate abducted children.
  • Encourage solutions that benefit both parents.
  • Submit admissible documents as part of the application in partner countries. 

A custody order is not always necessary to prove that a parent’s custodial rights were violated, as proof of parenthood or marriage can be used instead. When a child is returned to their habitual residence, it is done based on the best interests of the child, and their immigration status or nationality is not a factor. The Hague Convention provides a crucial framework for resolving international custody disputes prioritizing the child’s well-being.

CAN THE COURT DENY A RETURN?

It is important to note that under specific circumstances, the court may deny the return of a child, and these exceptions can vary from country to country. The court may deny the following: 

  • Risk to the child where they are exposed to physical or psychological harm.
  • The child objects if they are old enough.
  • More than a year has passed, and the child adapts to their new home.
  • The custodial parent agrees to let the child remain.
  • The return would violate human rights and fundamental freedoms
  • The custodial parents seeking return are not exercising rights of custody during wrongful removal. 

The Hague Convention provides various procedures for coordinating international child abduction cases. It’s important to note that the exceptions for denying the return of a child can vary from country to country.

CHALLENGES PARENTS MAY FACE

When parents are dealing with international child custody disputes, they often face a variety of hurdles they need to overcome. One of the most significant challenges is simply navigating the legal system of another country. This can involve language barriers, unfamiliar legal procedures, and cultural differences that can make it difficult for parents to advocate for their rights effectively. 

Additionally, parents may struggle to locate and communicate with their children, especially if the other parent is hiding them. In some cases, parents may also face obstacles related to travel, such as visa restrictions or prohibitive travel costs. International child custody cases can be highly stressful and emotionally taxing for parents. That’s why it’s essential to have the right support and guidance throughout the process.

GET THE HELP YOU NEED

Acting fast is crucial when facing an international child custody case, and having an attorney who can file a Hague Convention application on short notice is essential. It’s crucial to seek legal counsel with knowledge and experience in Hague proceedings to navigate these complex cases successfully.

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph are highly experienced in cases involving international child custody disputes in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. They have vast experience with the Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. 

If you’re interested in learning more, see our featured Hague Decisions:

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Who Gets the Pets in an Illinois Divorce?

Divorce is a complex and emotional time.  While much attention goes to child custody determinations in Illinois divorce cases, one contentious subject that many initially overlook is who gets the pets. 

Man’s best friend, furry children, four-legged friends. Our pets play a significant role in our family dynamics. And when the “pack” is disrupted through divorce or separation, many pet parents are left heartbroken and confused as to what happens next.

At Masters Law Group, we understand the significant role that pets play in our lives and the emotional attachment that comes with them. If you are going through a divorce, you may be wondering who gets to keep your cherished pet and whether “pet custody” is a possibility.

Here’s what you need to know.

How Divorce Laws on Pets Are Changing

Previously, family law cases rarely mentioned pets except in domestic violence situations. Over half of the states permit domestic violence restraining orders to include provisions safeguarding pets, mainly due to the fact that abusers often threaten or harm animals as a means of intimidating family members.

Recently, states have recognized that pets possess a special value to families that can’t be measured solely in monetary terms—despite being considered property. It’s because of this that courts have elevated pets to a status someplace between an inanimate object and a person. Illinois is among the states that have taken this concept a step further by mandating judges to consider the well-being of the pet in divorce cases. This is a significant leap, as it comes with the same standard used by judges when deciding child custody.

When is a Pet a Marital Asset in Illinois?

It’s common in divorce to have disputes over pets, such as dogs, and cats, that are considered part of the family.  The Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act provides custody-like provisions regarding the family pet, also known as a ‘companion animal’ upon a divorce. Marital assets are defined as properties acquired during the marriage. Except for the following instances:

  • Who originally purchased or adopted the pet?
  • Who takes care of the pet on a day-to-day basis? 
  • The ability of each spouse to care for the pet. 
  • The emotional attachment of each spouse to the pet.
  • Any agreements made before or during the marriage regarding pet ownership. 

If the court determines that the companion animal is not a marital asset, the owner will receive their non-marital property. If the court determines that the companion animal is a marital asset, then the court will allocate sole or joint ownership and responsibility for the animal. In doing so, the court must consider the well-being of the companion animal.

Fortunately, Illinois law recognizes that pets hold a special place in families and takes their well-being seriously when determining ownership during divorce proceedings.

How Does the Court Consider the “Well-Being” of the Pet?

It’s worth noting that, unlike child custody (now known as Allocation of Parental Responsibilities), pet custody in Illinois is not based on the pet’s “best interests”. If one spouse can demonstrate that they have been mainly responsible for the daily care and well-being of the pet, including feeding, grooming, exercising, and providing medical care, the court is more likely to award ownership to that spouse.

If you want to retain ownership of your pet after a divorce, it’s important to have evidence that shows your involvement in the pet’s life. This can include photographs and receipts for pet-related expenses such as veterinary bills. These documents show the court your commitment to caring for the pet and the bond you share with them.

It’s important to note that courts may consider parental responsibilities and parenting time when determining pet ownership during a divorce. Children oftentimes share a strong bond with family pets, and a spouse can argue that the majority of parenting time could be affected. If spouses can’t agree on pet ownership, they may need to go to court to have a judge make a decision.

Couples can settle disputes about pets through mediation when a divorce case doesn’t go to court. Regardless of the approach chosen, finding a solution that suits one’s specific circumstances is critical.

Final Thoughts

Pets are important in divorce cases because they represent not only a shared asset but also an emotional connection between the spouses. Determining their custody and care can be a complex and emotionally charged aspect of the divorce process. As such, you should ensure you have excellent legal representation to negotiate or prove your right to the ownership of your pet in an Illinois divorce.

If you’re contemplating divorce or separation and have concerns regarding your pet, property division, parental responsibilities, or other family law matters, reach out to the experienced attorneys at Masters Law Group here today.

 

Does Divorce Affect Adoptions in Illinois?

Parents who adopt aim to give the child/children a stable, loving environment to grow up in. Couples rarely adopt children with plans to divorce. But as we know, it doesn’t always pan out that way. 

After any adoption, with respect to minor children, if the parties divorce, the adoptive parent may have the same duties and parental responsibilities in regard to child support and other issues as though the minor child was his or her natural child. Here’s what you need to know.

Different Types of Adoption in Illinois

There are four main types of minor adoption that are commonly used in Illinois:

  • Related Adoption: Also called a “kinship” adoption, occurs in a situation where the child is adopted by family members, i.e, stepparent, grandparent, sibling, or aunt and uncle. This form of adoption is often the easiest to navigate, because some procedures and requirements may be waived. 
  • Agency Adoption:  In an agency adoption, the parents receive the child from the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) or a licensed private adoption agency. The biological parents have already surrendered the child to the state or had their parental rights terminated.
  • Private Adoption: A private adoption occurs when the adoptive parents receive the child directly from the biological family. 
  • Standby Adoption: A standby adoption is a legal arrangement that becomes effective after a specific event occurs, such as the death of a biological parent.

It’s important to note that Illinois also allows for adult adoptions. Adult adoption happens when a person over 18 is adopted by loved ones they have lived with for a substantial amount of time. The adult being adopted must give consent. However, biological parents do not need to give their approval.

Impact of Divorce on Adoption

When a married couple decides to adopt a child, they typically do so together, as joint petitioners. This means that both parents are legally responsible for the child, and both must consent to any decisions regarding the child’s upbringing, education, and medical care. However, if the couple divorces before the adoption is finalized, the situation becomes more complicated.

In Illinois, the adoption process is generally governed by the Illinois Adoption Act. According to this act, if a married couple begins the adoption process and then decides to divorce before the adoption is finalized, the court must determine whether the adoption is in the best interests of the child.

The court will consider various factors when making this determination, including the child’s age, health, and well-being, as well as the ability of each parent to provide a stable and loving home for the child. If the court determines that the adoption is still in the child’s best interests, the adoption can proceed, but the non-adopting spouse will no longer be considered a legal parent of the child.

On the other hand, if the court determines that the adoption is no longer in the child’s best interests, the adoption will be terminated, and the child will remain in the care of their birth parents or legal guardians.

Impact of Divorce on Stepparent Adoption

In some cases, a stepparent may wish to adopt their spouse’s child after a divorce. This process is known as stepparent adoption, and it is subject to different rules than traditional adoption.

Under Illinois law, a stepparent may adopt their spouse’s child if the following conditions are met:

  • The stepparent is married to the child’s legal parent.
  • The child’s other legal parent has consented to the adoption or had their parental rights terminated by a court.
  • The adoption is in the best interests of the child.

If the stepparent meets these requirements, they may petition the court to adopt the child. However, if the legal parent of the child objects to the adoption, the court will have to determine whether the adoption is in the best interests of the child.

If the legal parent does not object, the adoption can proceed without the need for a court hearing, and the stepparent will become the child’s legal parent.

Conclusion

Divorce can have a significant impact on adoption proceedings in Illinois, and it is important to understand the laws and regulations that govern these situations. If you are considering adoption or are going through a divorce while in the process of adopting, it is highly recommended that you consult with an experienced family law attorney who can help guide you through the legal process and protect your rights and the best interests of the child.

At Masters Law Group, our team of skilled attorneys can help guide you through the divorce process and explain the legal implications of how adopted children could be affected.

Schedule a consultation today to begin the conversation.